In the third season of the “Magic Forbidden Book Catalogue” in his lifetime, he arrived on time in October. This series is qualified to be “high popularity” both in China and in Japan, but there are still many discerning fans in China who are questioning the level of animation and production of this series. .

At the B station, although the “Magic Ban Book Catalogue” scored 9.1 points in the third quarter, but the number of people relying on sentiment scores is still a majority, the Tucao plot can not understand, there are not many people who are not satisfied with the production:

Most people are complaining that the cartoon plot of “The Magical Forbidden” series is very “fascinated”. This is not to blame the audience. The novels of “Magic Banned Books Catalogue” are very large, different organizations, different and powerful. Relationships, multiple identities of different roles, denominations of various colors, “fans” are indeed fans of his reasons, but the animated version of “Magic” can be said to be a more animated party, for those who have not seen The original friend’s work is very unfriendly, and it is also a torture of the original party. .

The story of “Magic Forbidden” is very jumping. Because the animation can’t be all-inclusive, the supervision of making this animation can’t take its essence, so people feel that the story is flat, and it’s not clear, it’s not The situation occurred in the third quarter, the first season of the “Magic Forbidden”, the second season, this is the case. The story jumps and the rhythm control is not good, which makes it difficult for friends who have not seen the original to fall into a face of arrogance. .

For the original party, the friends who have seen the original work in the dark war will think that this part should be a pretty chapter in the Old Testament, and then the dark war in “Magic 3”? At present, the episodes of 2 episodes are very messy, and the stories of hard-working and hard-working are not disappointing. It can be said that it is very disappointing. In the eyes of many “old drivers”, “Magic 3” is bound to be bad. Why? .

The author found such a post in the post bar. When the production lineup of “Magic ban 3” was announced at that time, it was confirmed that the supervision was the premise of Jinzhibo, and there was a prediction that the “Magic ban 3” must be customized. . Looking at it now, this prediction has become a reality. .

And the rotten spear of the “Magic Forbidden” animation is undoubtedly directed at the animation supervision of this series of animations – Jin Zhibo. .

This is a terrible animation supervision for the famous, the sunspots call it “bath supervision”, because he likes to take pictures of the long and smelly beautiful girl taking a shower, and some should have been bloody. Fandu was made a taste of harem welfare, and the popular IP such as “Magic” was put into his hands. After being bad, it was notorious. The evaluation of the supervision in China is almost negative. In addition to the “magic ban”, the “School Girl Raiders” of the year can also be described as one of the failed “bath supervision” fame, and interested friends can feel the boring of his works. .

In fact, the “Magic Forbidden Book Catalogue” can be used as the peak work of the popular fashion of the light novels at that time. It is indeed a very wonderful light novel. Although it is very difficult to adapt, it can be adapted by a supervisor to be plain and tasteless. Works that people can’t understand. As a sister of “The Magical Forbidden”, “Science Super Electromagnetic Gun” is very popular, and it has received rave reviews. If you carefully compare two works, especially the “Electromagnetic Cannon S”, the first 16 episodes of “Absolute Ability” The Evolutionary Plan, and exactly the same story in “The Magical Forbidden”, you can clearly feel the excellentness of the “Electric Gun” animation and the lack of the “Magic”. It is clearly a story. .

The production company is J.C.STAFF. Why is the animation of “Magic Forbidden” not as good as “Electric Gun”? The reason also comes down to the different levels of supervision. The supervision of “Electromagnetic Gun” is Longjing Longxue, not Jinzhibo. .

Speaking of the head, the success of a work, to a large extent, depends on the level of supervision, which is the “animation director”. Although the investor can decide the direction of the story, the script grasps the level of the story, but the overall level of performance still depends on supervision. Different animations supervise the different understandings of the original works, and different ways of presentation will determine the different perceptions of the works. .

The author has always advocated a sentence, that is, “look at the animation, it is actually supervision.” .

How can an animation behave, and ultimately it is still the animation supervision, the difference between the different animation supervisions brings the changes in the works is very significant, and the supervision of knowledge, background, accumulation, will also bring to the works Very different effects and even depth.

Just as many people mentioned the works of Xinfang Zhaozhi, those unique and impressive mirrors. When they mentioned Xinhaicheng, they thought of the beautiful background of Meicheng wallpaper. When it comes to Hayao Miyazaki, it is the Ghibli signature. Fairytale style and story. What different supervisions bring to animation works is a style, even a good or bad, but not absolute. .

Just like 2016, relying on your name. “Deeply let people remember the name of Xin Haicheng. His work in the period of the art studio of the game studio shows his style. Beautiful scenery, the clouds under the sun, the speeding tram, the color is warm, looks soft and warm, this is one of his understanding of the animation works, the work relies on the beautiful scenery to create a beautiful atmosphere. This is his original intention to make such a style of work. .

But his work has been criticized as “empty and no content”, to “second centimeters per second”, the author believes that this is already a relatively complete work of his work, but still many people question the story without substance There is only enough room for delusion, but there is no story of content, not a story that people want to see. Then, there is the later “Your name. The leap of “, your name. The birth of “,” and his accumulation of previous works, is not unrelated. .

The progress of the work has a direct relationship with the accumulation of supervised knowledge. The author believes, “Your name. Compared with the progress of “5 cm per second”, it has a close relationship with Xin Haicheng’s experience in the past 9 years. If “the speed of five centimeters per second” gives people a feeling of “regret of youth”, then “your name. The ending of the book seems to make up for the regret that the original tree and Mingli did not together. Xin Haicheng gave a perfect ending, as if it was a portrayal of his family business. .

There are many people who like to take out the “performance” of Xinhaicheng, compared with Miyazaki’s works. Some people will criticize Xinhaicheng’s works without the “thickness” and “depth” of Hayao Miyazaki’s works. I want the author to say, “This is not nonsense. The two supervisors are 30 years old, and their resumes are far away. I think that the work of Xin Haicheng in his 40s does not have the depth of Hayao Miyazaki. It is not supposed to be so.” “. .

From the resume, Hayao Miyazaki was born in Toei, and stayed in the insect animation. It is the most basic place of Japanese animation. The nutrients absorbed there are of course different from those made by Xin Haicheng. What is the origin of Xinhaicheng? The earliest is the art company of the game company. You took the original work of Xinhaicheng and Dongying from the game company’s art. The huge difference in resumes naturally led to the huge difference in the thickness and depth of the two works. .

Finally, returning to the topic of “Magic Forbidden”, why do you think that “Magic Forbidden” does not understand, boring, and Jin Zhibo’s understanding of the original work, understanding, and understanding of animation, there is no small relationship, supervision Have you read the original work well, have you understood the original work well, and have you liked the original work? This is very relevant to whether the supervision can reflect the essence of the work. The supervision of Jin Zhibo’s assembly line did not highlight the highlights of the work, and did not sort out the logic of the work well, thus causing the situation that the “magic ban” is more embarrassing than the “electromagnetic gun”. .

Animation is good, when it comes to the head, it is still supervised.